ORAL ARGUMENT TODAY, NOVEMBER 18, 2026, EVERLOVING HOME HEALTH CARE, INC. et al., v. JOSEPH AMIRIAN PHYSICAL THERAPY, B349733 /19STCV36658

We argued today before the California Court of Appeal in a case presenting a remarkable question:

Can a criminal defendant who admitted wrongdoing, pleaded guilty, paid restitution, and later obtained a procedural vacatur of the conviction use equity to recover that restitution from the victims?

The panel appeared deeply skeptical of that proposition.

At its core, the respondent sought to transform post-conviction relief under Penal Code section 1473.7 into an affirmative right to recoup funds paid to the very parties harmed by the conduct underlying the criminal case. The trial court had concluded that once the conviction and restitution order were vacated, the respondents were entitled to recover approximately $240,000 in restitution payments under theories of unjust enrichment and restitution.

During oral argument, the justices repeatedly focused on the extraordinary consequences of that rule.

The central point we emphasized was straightforward:

Equity exists to prevent unjust enrichment, not to reward admitted misconduct.

Respondent admitted the underlying conduct. The criminal proceedings ended in a guilty plea. No court ever entered a finding of factual innocence. No court ever determined that the victims suffered no losses. Yet respondent’s theory would permit a person who admitted wrongdoing to invoke equitable principles and recover money previously paid as restitution.

A procedural defect may justify vacating a conviction. It does not automatically erase the historical facts, eliminate equitable defenses, or create an affirmative entitlement to restitution from private parties.

Another significant issue involved the doctrine of unclean hands. We argued that a litigant who admittedly used false credentials and engaged in deceptive conduct should not be permitted to invoke equity to obtain reimbursement from those harmed by that conduct. The court’s questions suggested substantial interest in whether equitable principles can override a mechanical application of post-conviction relief statutes.

The panel also addressed the dismissal of appellants’ fraud claim in a tentative ruling.

Importantly, the Court appeared receptive to our argument that, at a minimum, leave to amend should have been granted. We emphasized that California law strongly favors amendment where a reasonable possibility exists that pleading defects can be cured. The discussion suggested the panel viewed the fraud allegations differently from several of the other dismissed claims and was open to allowing that cause of action to proceed.

One noteworthy development involved respondent’s recent effort to file supplemental briefing concerning factual innocence. We argued that the request was both untimely and unnecessary because no finding of factual innocence exists in the record and because the issue had already been addressed in the parties’ principal briefs. The panel did not address the supplemental briefing request.  It does not alter the fundamental question before the Court.

While appellate outcomes are never certain, the arguments generated substantial engagement from the bench, particularly on the broader equitable implications of allowing a criminal defendant who admitted wrongdoing to wield unjust enrichment principles against the recipients of criminal restitution.

The case now stands submitted for decision.

The result could provide important guidance on the intersection of criminal vacatur statutes, restitution recovery actions, unjust enrichment principles, and the continued vitality of equitable defenses such as unclean hands where a conviction has been vacated but no finding of factual innocence has ever been made.

Here is the Appellants Opening Brief:  Opening Brief

Here is the Respondent’s Brief:  Amirian’s Brief

Here is the Reply Brief:  Reply Brief

HERE IS A VIDEO OF THE ORAL ARGUMENT:

Posted in: